skip to content

Insurance Agency Benchmarks: $15M–$50M Agencies

At the $15M–$50M revenue tier, the gap between Best Practices and median operating performance becomes a deal-process variable. A 10-percentage-point spread on operating margin at $30M is $3M in annual EBITDA.

Best Practices vs median: directional benchmarks for $15M–$50M agencies

  • Operating margin: Best Practices ~28–32% · Median ~18–23%
  • Pro forma EBITDA margin: Best Practices ~30–34% · Median ~20–25%
  • Total compensation ratio: Best Practices ~54–59% · Median ~61–66%
  • Service & admin compensation ratio: Best Practices ~17–22% · Median ~23–29%
  • Revenue per employee: Best Practices ~$200K–$240K · Median ~$155K–$185K
  • Organic growth: Best Practices ~9–12% · Median ~5–8%
  • Client retention: Best Practices ~93–96% · Median ~89–92%

Where the leverage is: service & admin compensation

At $30M in revenue, every percentage point of service compensation ratio is $300K. Moving from a median 27% to a Best Practices 19% is $2.4M in annual margin.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good profit margin for a $25M insurance agency?

Best Practices agencies in the $15M–$50M tier typically operate at 28–32% operating margin and 30–34% pro forma EBITDA margin. The industry median is 18–23% operating margin. A $25M agency operating below 22% EBITDA is structurally underperforming relative to top-quartile peers.

How does service cost ratio affect an agency’s M&A multiple?

Significantly. Buyers value EBITDA, and service & admin compensation is the largest variable cost line affecting it. An agency with a structurally low service compensation ratio commands a higher multiple. The gap can be one to two turns of EBITDA on the multiple itself, on top of the EBITDA difference.

For the full benchmark framework: Insurance Agency Benchmarks: Best Practices vs Median by Size Tier

See how COVU OS helps $15M–$50M agencies close the gap to Best Practices and protect margin at scale

Directional benchmarks summarized from publicly released Big “I” / Reagan Consulting Best Practices Study figures and COVU’s operational experience across 50+ insurance agencies and $200M+ in premium. Not audited financial data.

Scroll to Top