Insurance Agency Valuation by State: What Your Agency Is Worth in 2026

Insurance agency valuation is not a single number applied uniformly across the country. Regional M&A activity, buyer concentration, book composition, state-specific market dynamics, and local economic conditions all affect what buyers will pay for agencies in each state. A $5M commercial book in Dallas does not transact the same way as a $5M personal lines book in rural Pennsylvania. This resource covers what independent P&C agencies are worth in 2026, state by state, with context on the M&A market, buyer types, and the factors that move multiples up or down in each market.

State Valuation Guides

Select your state for a valuation guide built specifically for independent P&C agency owners in your market:

Why State Context Matters in Agency Valuation

Buyer demand is not uniform across the country. PE-backed platforms are more active in high-growth Southeast and Southwest markets. Larger independent acquirers tend to concentrate in markets where they already have carrier density. Some states generate more competitive bid processes than others simply because of buyer concentration. State-level M&A activity also determines how long your process takes and how much negotiating leverage you have going in.

Beyond buyer dynamics, the composition of agency books varies significantly by state. Florida agencies carry hurricane exposure. California agencies carry wildfire and surplus lines complexity. Ohio agencies lean toward manufacturing workers’ compensation. Each of these book characteristics affects how buyers model the risk they are acquiring and what they are willing to pay for it.

For the complete valuation framework: Agency Valuation Calculator

Schedule a free valuation conversation with COVU